Planner Experiment Results: Not What I Expected!




The Planner Experiment didn’t turn out the way I expected – and that’s probably a good thing.  I’m pretty sure I was hoping to get a list of planner options from which I would randomly choose one and miraculously stick to it forever, or at least for a long time.  But it didn’t happen that way.  Instead of a list of planning systems, you all gave me great advice and some things to think about.  You tried to figure out what I needed so that I could finally have planner peace again.  And I thank you for that.  You are all wonderful and I’m blessed to have you reading my blog.

Since you had such great advice, I decided to start this post by sharing some of it.  I know there are other people besides me who are struggling to find a measure of planner peace and these suggestions could be helpful for them, too. Since most of this is available in the comments, what’s in this post is a summary.

Cat:  But you keep going back to compact Franklin Covey two pages per day?

What is it exactly you do NOT like about the Franklin Covey two pages per day that you keep going back to?   This is a great question.  Anytime you’re considering switching or feeling dissatisfaction with your current set-up, ask yourself what it is you don’t like.  If you can’t fix it, at least you have a better idea of what to look for in the new system.

Cat:  IF IT WORKS…THEN WORK IT! The grass (or planner) is not always greener on the other side! This is SO true!  I can’t tell you how many times I’ve decided to switch sizes or formats and was in the new size and format only minutes before I realized it wasn’t an improvement and ran back to my Franklin Covey.

Elena (  I would think that with the amount of writing you do on a daily basis that you would be hard-pressed to switch to a format that would hinder how much you write. You want freedom in your planner, not feeling like you’re being suppressed.  And this is one reason why there are so many different options.  Elena hit the nail on the head. I want lots of writing room and freedom within structure.  Trying to find a system that goes against my basic needs will never work.  That’s true of everyone.  If you like writing, you can’t choose a system with no room to write.  If you don’t like writing, you don’t need a lot of room.  If you write large, you probably won’t be happy with a tiny planner that requires tiny writing.  So the first rule in choosing a planner format is to choose one that meets our basic needs.

Elena (  My other vote would be to still use classic/A5 (as you need space) and just use plain lined or grid paper and perhaps draw out different types of layouts (either weekly or daily) and test them out that way without spending money on formatted pages first.  There’s no rule that says you can’t use blank paper.  Blank paper can be a very effective planning tool.

Doug Puryear (  homey – read your requirements. Haven’t you already picked the right planner for you right there? Would you consider trying it for 6 months instead of one? Wouldn’t that make your life better? Or are you on the quest for the Holy Grail?  Duh.  Doug’s right.  My “rules” outlined a lot of details about the planner I want.  Sometimes we know what we want but we still think something else will be better or more interesting or more exciting.  The truth is that time management and doing the do’s on our list is work.  It’s not necessarily fun.  And having the right planner doesn’t make it more fun to clean the kitchen or do the laundry.  A planner is a tool.  When my husband chooses a tool for a remodeling job he needs to do, his primary focus is whether it will do the job and if it’s the right price.  Obviously we can have a little more fun with our planners than he can with his tools, but the bottom line is the same – a planner is a tool.

I wish I could tell Doug I wasn’t searching for the Holy Grail.  I didn’t think I was but maybe I am.  Or maybe I’m just bored with my to-do’s and hoping a different planner will make them more fun.  Has anybody had success with that?  I’m guessing not.

Bree (  I do think any planner is better than no planner, but I don’t think any planner will work if we stick with it.  I think you’re right, Bree.  I think one reason Ashley can make any planner work is because she’s staying with a similar style.  She knows what she likes and the different formats she tries are all within that style.  If she tried using something different, like GTD, I don’t think it would work for her.  We have basic needs in our planning system and certain planners meet those needs better than others.  Within the style we like, there can be other options, though.

Bree (   What are the things that you reference when you take your planner out of your purse away from home? (Not the just in cases, the actual things you refer to). What do you like most about the ring binders that you keep returning to even though the pages inside don’t always work? Texture? Color? Layout? Clasp style?  What are the things that create friction and prevent you from using a planner that’s working okay?  (For me, I’ve learned I won’t deal with all the folding pages like DIY Fish, I must have a binder that lays flat, I must have dated pages, and when I design my own pages I have to print a ton because when I run out I don’t always have the time/energy to get the next batch going).  What colors, font styles and designs make you happy? What colors and designs bore, repel or frustrate you?  What planning tools have intrigued you, if money were no object?  These are great questions, Bree, and I think that before any of us make changes we should ask ourselves these.  The more we can figure out ahead of time, the more money and time we’ll save in trying to find a system we like and that works for us. 

Helen:  I have two thoughts on this – On the one hand, you need something that works the way you do. On the other, if you really want to prove the claim you make in the title, that *any* planner can work, you need to go 100% out of your comfort zone, to something totally different to what you’ve used before.  Wow, Helen.  You’re absolutely right.  To prove that claim, I need to do something different.  But in my “rules”, I pretty much laid out the same system I’m currently using.  The truth is – I don’t want to try something different.  I want to try something just a little bit different than what I’m currently using.  I had no idea I was doing that.

Jane: I really think that you should stick with compact Franklin Covey 2ppd. I know it’s boring, but it really does seem to work best for you. At least my impression is that you complain less on your blog about missing things or feeling stressed out when you stick with that system. That’s probably not what you wanted to hear, though.  You’re right, Jane.  That’s not what I wanted to hear but I’m hearing that a lot.  Even when people suggest other options, they end with the idea that I probably really should stick with my Franklin Covey.  Sometimes the best system for us is the one we already have.

Kim (  Ultimately, pick whichever has the least amount of friction for you and makes you feel like you’re actually happy and getting things done. If some part of it is getting in the way, perhaps it isn’t the size but the type of planner. I’ve heard that there’s a big thing surrounding ring-bound planners called “perfect size, but too small pages”.  If this is the case for you, I suggest ditching them altogether and try a different ring system like the discbound system, their pages tend to be closer to the actual size of the notebook itself while lending to format of a notebook and flexibility of a ring-bound binder. Interesting idea.  I had never heard of that but it’s exactly right.  I’ve never considered the discbound system but maybe I’ll look into it.

And finally, I thought this was a good note to end on:

Kim (  And lastly, you might totally hate the challenge if it turns out that a few days in it’s not the way YOU plan and what you like. That’s perfectly okay, we all have our preferences. If this happens, I suggest forgoing the challenge and going back to the last system that worked best for you and find a way to be happy with it. You probably don’t need to even lug it around with you. I leave my Bullet Journal at home most of the time.  When I go out for dinner and errands, no need to bring a planner type deal with me!  Instead I bring a pocket notebook just in case anything comes up that I need to write down. Back to what I was saying, do what’s best for you, don’t keep doing the challenge to try to please us, we read your articles because we like you, but it shouldn’t come at the expense of your own happiness. Good luck with whatever you decide to do!  You’re right, Kim.  No one can choose a planner for us – we have to choose for ourselves.  I’ve sat down with my family many times and forced them to choose one for me and then I promptly used a different one.  Actually, that can be a good strategy for figuring out which one you really want to use!  Unfortunately it doesn’t sit well with the people you forced to help you for the millionth time.

So what did I decide?  In case you’re interested, I’m going to use –

Personal Filofax Guildford
DIYFish Life Mapping Pages

DIYFish Life Mapping System

I’ll keep you posted on how I use them.  And thank you again for all your help and support.

The following two tabs change content below.
Born in Kentucky, I am a wife and mom to 1 son and 2 daughters . I have an ink pen obsession, as well as a love for all things planner. I have been married for 10 years to my high school crush. I am a member of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.

Latest posts by Steph Caldwell (see all)

10 thoughts on “Planner Experiment Results: Not What I Expected!

  1. Lots of insight. Thank you for sharing. I love reading about layouts and seeing what others are doing. I haven’t found perfection, but I have found perfect for me right now. Good luck!

  2. Congratulations on your decision. I loved reading all the comments. They’ve made me give my Franklinfaxruntimer a good hard look. For now, it makes sense. Now if I could only find the right pen

    1. Made me laugh. Fortunately, pens have never been an issue for me. I really don’t care as long as it’s a clicker. I don’t like taking the time to remove a cap.

  3. I tried to comment on the last post where you asked for advice, but it doesn’t seem to have actually posted. I was going to suggest either compact Franklin Covey or personal filofax with Franklin Covey or diyfish pages, so I’m glad you chose one of those 🙂 Have you considered getting a custom made binder? Van den spek make really good ones from what I hear. It seems to me that the compact/personal size and 2ppd works best for you, but that you’re bored with it. Having a fun binder or bright colors on the pages might help alleviate the boredom. Fish might even be willing to come up with some brightly colored page borders you could print directly on the pages if you ask. Good luck!

    1. Jane – I do occasionally put washi tape on the Fish pages to brighten them up. I enjoy doing that since I don’t care for plain white, although it’s not that big of a deal. My daughter-in-law got me some cute nature stickers, too, so I’ve been using those some.

      I actually had a Van Der Spek but it had one of those big pockets at the back and I didn’t like that. I’d like to have a Gillio but they’re a bit expensive for me right now.

  4. Another thought just occurred to me. Have you considered daytime? They have a binder you might like called malibu. I can’t get my phone to copy and paste the full website correctly, but if you go to and search malibu portable you should find what I’m talking about. They have fun colors like red, gold and purple now until addition to the usual earth tones. The ring setup on the portable size is exactly the same as Franklin Covey compact and Filofax personal and the malibu binder is slightly wider than a filofax, so it will hold Franklin Covey pages easily. Daytimer also has 2ppd layouts that are very similar to Franklin Covey if you really want a change. The paper quality is slightly lower than Franklin Covey, but a lot better than filofax. I’ve been using the malibu binder with diyfish pages since January and I really like it. I might go back to Franklin Covey pages this year though because I’ve had a few issues with making time to print my own pages.

    1. My daughter has the malibu in lime green. I got it for myself but I didn’t like it. It was too big. When I buy a new planner, I compare the dimensions to my current planner. I like the ones that are only as big as they need to be. Some of them have extra room at the top and the side and I don’t like that. If I’m going to use an extra large compact, I’d just as soon use a classic. I do love the colors of the Malibu, though.

  5. I’ve been looking for my holy grail too. I think it’s more about wanting something different out of life (I’m in a transitional time). I’m also itching for the clean slate feeling that a new planner and new year bring. It’s been hard to keep using my 75% done old planner, but it works if I use it. Maybe it’s just the fall season… but whenever you share any of your planner pages, I can see how they worked for the day you were facing. Thanks for all you do – it has helped me figure out my own planning personality much better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *